The Facts
Instructor: Professor Stephen A. Bernhardt, PhD
Tuesdays 4:00-630
Room: 127 English building
Office Phone: 646-2027
Office: 222 English
email sbernhar@nmsu.edu
classlist: comtec-l@listserv.nmsu.edu
Office hous: Monday Wed 1:30-2:30; Tuesday 3-4 and by appointment
If you have questions or need help, please stop by my office or send me email.
Required Textbook:
Davis, Martha. Scientific Papers and Presentations. San Diego: Academic Press, 1997.
If you want to develop your control of sentence structure and command of professional style, I recommend my own book. It is written for self-study, and I would be happy to work through it with you.
This course is the first semester of a two semester workshop to help McNair Scholars develop their research for publication and presentation.
Students develop a proposal for research they will conduct during summer internships. Throughout the course, students engage in a variety of communicative tasks related to their research and careers: participating in email conversations, preparing materials for graduate school admission, and joining conversations of professionals who share the research interests of the students.
A frequent format for classes will be some time in lecture and discussion, some time spent discussing assignments, and then some time spent analyzing and critiquing samples of student writing. We will count on each other throughout the course, sometimes in small groups, sometimes in pairs, sometimes as a full class. I will give each of you careful criticism of your work and make myself available for individual conferences at your convenience. I like to help you with your projects as you work on them, rather than evaluate them after you are finished (though I must also do that!).
We can invite guests to our class to discuss their lives as researchers and writers. If you know of someone--perhaps your mentor, someone from the university or scientific community, or a McNair Scholar who had gone on to graduate school--who might make an interesting guest for our class, please talk to me about arrangements.
I hope you will catch some of my enthusiasm for the challenge of research communication, and that you will develop your own interests. Build your own reference library on scientific publishing and communication. Find out what is in the library. Browse the current journals in your field. Find out where the conferences are and when. Begin to make personal contacts with professionals in your chosen field. Becoming a professional who communicates well and enjoys the challenge of writing for publication is the overall goal of this course, and it can only be accomplished with your full enthusiastic initiative.
Requirements:
Your final grade will be an overall assessment (letter grade) based on your portfolio of work completed during the term, including evaluations of written work, oral presentations, and contributions to class. Self-initiated work can be documented through memos and included with the portfolio (attendance at meetings or lectures, special projects outside of class, continuing research initiatives with your mentor or in other situations). You will receive extensive feedback on your work, from me and your classmates. Drafts will receive a check (satisfactory), check plus (good work) or check minus (needs more work). Final versions of assignments will be graded with a letter grade. Work can be revised and resubmitted up until the end of the term, but quality work must be submitted on a timely basis throughout the term to achieve a high grade of A or B. Let me know when you consider a draft ready to receive a grade.
I will give you an evaluation of your progress at any time you request
it–the grade I would give you if your work continued at the current level.Late
work will be graded down. Being unprepared for class, not attending, or
not participating will negatively affect your grade.
Students with Disabilities
If you have or believe you have a disability, you may wish to self-identify. You can do so by providing documentation to the Office for Services for Students with Disabilities, located at Garcia Annex (phone: 646-6840). Appropriate accommodations may then be provided for you.
If you have a condition which may affect your ability to exit safely from the premises in an emergency or which may cause an emergency during class, you are encouraged to discuss this in confidence with the instructor and/or the director of Disabled Students Programs. If you have general questions about the Americans with Disabilities ACT (ADA), call 646-3635.
Assignments
Feb 1 Working annotated bibliography (5-10 items). An annotated
bibliography has the complete bibliographic citation, in the approved format
according to your style guide. Write a 2-5 sentence summary of the content
of the article, noting what kind of research it is, what its claims are,
what methods it uses to investigate its hypothesis, and what its key findings
and conclusions are.
Read Davis, Ch 2-3
Feb 8 Revised draft plan of work for the research project, with
dates, activities, anticipated issue or problems, necessary actions. Provide
a copy to your mentor and one to me.
Working annotated bibliography (10-15 items)
Read Davis, Ch 4
Feb 15 Abstract of your research project
Read Davis, Ch 5, App 3
Feb 22 Review a journal that would be a likely target for your
work. In a brief memo (no more than 2 pages), outline the purpose and audience
of the journal, the kinds of subjects and articles they publish, the length
of contributions, the advice to authors, etc.
Revised working bibliography (15 items)
Read Davis, Ch 10, App 7
Feb 29 Draft literature review: Your literature review synthesizes the information from your background research. It presents trends, demonstrates agreements and disagreements in the field, highlights methods that have been used to investigate the topic, and concludes by pointing out the need for the study you are about to propose. The literature review should cover 15-20 items. It can include general background sources, such as textbook chapters, as well as specific studies published in journals. It is primarily based on published literature, but may include material from lectures, interviews with experts, and web-published information. The lit review is written in paragraph format. It might include theoretical diagrams, tables of consolidate results from across studies, maps, or other visual renderings. Attach your annotated bibliography. Submit to me and your mentor for comments and revision suggestions.
Mar 7 Presentations: The first presentation is to brief the class
on your background literature. Prepare 5–6 PowerPoint slides to accompany
your discussion. What are you studying and why? What are the key concepts
or constructs? What is known and well understood concerning your topic?
What disagreements characterize the research and scholarship? Can you map
the field with some sort of diagram? End with a statement of your own question
and a statement of need for your inquiry. The presentation should last
about 10 minutes with a few minutes for Q/A.
Read: Davis, Ch 6, 7
Mar 14 Presentations:
Read Davis, Ch 8, 9
Mar 21 Finish Presentations:
Progress reports with updated plan of work: What have you accomplished?
What remains to be accomplished? What problems are you having? What are
your plans for addressing those problems? Will you be ready to turn in
an approved proposal and be ready to start your research on time?
Read Davis, Ch 15, 16, App 12
Mar 28 Spring Break
Apr 4 Revised review of literature, submitted for grading
Read Davis, Ch 11, 12
April 4 Read Davis, Ch 13, 14
April 11 Draft research proposal to your mentor and me for feedback and revision suggestions. Present a full and formal draft, with title page with abstract and keywords, introduction, brief review of literature, statement of hypothesis or research questions, a full description of method, an annotated bibliography, budget, work schedule, and supporting materials (copies of instruments you will use, survey questions, test items, and anything else that needs to be approved before you begin collecting data).
April 18 Presentation #2: Present your research proposal to the class. Assume we are a review board or funding agency and you need our approval to go forward. State clearly the topic of your research, the purpose and significance, the hypothesis, the key constructs, and the theoretical grounding. Give a very brief review of the supporting literature, but concentrate on your methods and procedures. Show your schedule of work, list of supplies and equipment, and a budget. Use 5–8 supporting PowerPoint slides, using visuals to help your audience understand your project. Plan for 10-12 minutes and then take questions. Mentors and McNair staff are encouraged to attend.
April 25 Presentation #2
May 2 Presentation #2
Revised research proposal, submitted for grade with signatures
(mentor and McNair)
May 9 Meet for class evaluation (at regular time).
Draft research article.
Interview with a professional in your field.
Personal statement for application to graduate school.
Draft and final research report.
Conference presentation.